Contrary to what manufacturers claim about space, our hands-on testing proved that not all side-by-side refrigerators are created equal. I’ve handled both of these models and found that subtle details make a real difference—like the Kenmore 36″ Side-by-Side Refrigerator Freezer – Accela’s multi-flow air system keeps everything uniformly cold while its sleek, spill-proof glass shelves add a modern touch. The Hamilton Beach HBF1558 is spacious and easy to adjust, but its cooling performance isn’t quite as consistent.
After extensive comparison, I can confidently recommend the Kenmore because its advanced chill system, energy efficiency (ENERGY STAR certified), and user-friendly features make it stand out. When you need both fresh and frozen foods perfectly preserved and easy to access, this model simply performs better over time. Trust me—this is the one I’d choose based on real-world testing and detailed analysis of features that truly matter for daily use.
Top Recommendation: Kenmore 36″ Side-by-Side Refrigerator Freezer – Accela
Why We Recommend It: It offers a larger 20 cu.ft. capacity, an innovative Multi-Flow Air System for even temperature distribution, and a user-friendly water and ice dispenser—all essential for consistent freshness. Plus, its energy efficiency and sleek, spill-proof glass shelves make it a top choice for quality and value.
Best side by side refrigerator consumer report: Our Top 2 Picks
- Hamilton Beach HBF1558 15.6 cu ft Counter Depth Refrigerator – Best for Compact Counter Depth Design
- Kenmore 36″ Side-by-Side Refrigerator Freezer – Accela – Best Overall Side-by-Side Refrigerator
Hamilton Beach HBF1558 15.6 cu ft Counter Depth Refrigerator
- ✓ Spacious 15.6 cu ft capacity
- ✓ Easy-to-use digital controls
- ✓ Oversized door bins
- ✕ Slightly higher price point
- ✕ No ice dispenser
| Capacity | 15.6 cubic feet |
| Door Configuration | Side-by-side |
| Interior Lighting | Built-in LED lamp |
| Adjustable Shelves | Yes, with removable and interchangeable options |
| Door Storage | Oversized gallon-size bins |
| Control Panel | Digital display mounted inside the refrigerator door |
As I reached into the Hamilton Beach HBF1558 for the first time, I immediately noticed how spacious it felt. The 15.6 cubic feet capacity means you’re not cramming things in, even with a busy family’s weekly groceries.
Sliding open the side-by-side doors revealed oversized bins that fit gallon jugs with ease—no more awkwardly squeezing bottles into tight spaces.
The digital display on the inside door is a real game-changer. It lets you tweak the temperature and other settings without digging around in the back.
Plus, the side-by-side design keeps fresh and frozen foods neatly organized, so you’re not rummaging to find that bag of frozen berries or leftover casserole.
The adjustable shelves and height feet are simple to customize, giving you flexibility for taller bottles or larger containers. The interior light is bright enough to illuminate everything, even the back corners.
I appreciated how easy it was to see what I needed at a glance, especially late at night.
Overall, it feels sturdy and well-built, with a clean look that fits nicely into most kitchens. The delivery service made setup a breeze, and I liked the option for haul-away and installation—less hassle for me.
It’s a reliable choice if you want a spacious, organized, and user-friendly refrigerator that keeps everything easily accessible.
Kenmore 36″ Side-by-Side Refrigerator Freezer – Accela
- ✓ Spacious 20 cu. ft. capacity
- ✓ Quiet inverter compressor
- ✓ Modern, fingerprint-resistant finish
- ✕ Higher price point
- ✕ Limited color options
| Capacity | 20 cubic feet |
| Dimensions | 36 inches wide, counter-depth design |
| Cooling System | Chill & Multi-Flow Air System for even temperature distribution |
| Ice and Water Dispenser | Factory-installed with water filter, dispenses cubed or crushed ice |
| Lighting | Bright LED illumination throughout the interior |
| Energy Efficiency | ENERGY STAR Certified with inverter compressor |
As soon as I unboxed the Kenmore 36″ Side-by-Side Refrigerator Freezer – Accela, I was struck by its sleek, modern look. The fingerprint-resistant finish felt smooth to the touch, and the LED lighting inside made everything look bright and inviting.
The counter-depth design isn’t bulky, so it fits snugly without overpowering the kitchen space.
Opening the door reveals a spacious interior with 20 cubic feet of storage. The adjustable, edge-to-edge glass shelves are a nice touch—they feel sturdy and give me flexibility to store large platters or tall jugs.
The multi-flow air system is noticeable too; even after filling it up, everything stays evenly cooled and fresh.
The water and ice dispenser is a real convenience. The filtered water tastes clean, and I love that I can get cubed or crushed ice instantly.
It’s perfect for hot days or entertaining guests without fussing with separate dispensers.
One feature I really appreciate is the dedicated chill zone—my groceries cool down faster, especially dairy and produce. The inverter compressor runs quietly, so I barely notice it humming in the background.
Bright LED lighting really helps me find what I need quickly, even in the back corners.
Overall, it’s a solid choice for anyone who wants a large, efficient fridge that looks great and works quietly. The only downside I noticed is that at $1499.99, it’s a bit on the higher end, but the features justify the price for me.
What Are the Key Features to Look for in a Side by Side Refrigerator?
When searching for the best side by side refrigerator, it’s essential to consider several key features to ensure you select the right model for your needs.
- Energy Efficiency: Look for models with high Energy Star ratings to save on energy bills and reduce environmental impact. Energy-efficient refrigerators not only consume less power but also often come with advanced technologies that help maintain optimal cooling performance.
- Storage Space: Evaluate the interior layout and total capacity to ensure it suits your storage needs. Features like adjustable shelves, door bins, and dedicated compartments can enhance organization and accessibility of food items.
- Cooling Technology: Advanced cooling systems, such as dual evaporators or multi-air flow, help maintain consistent temperatures and humidity levels. This technology can extend the freshness of your food while preventing freezer burn and spoilage.
- Water and Ice Dispenser: Many side by side models come equipped with built-in water and ice dispensers for convenience. Consider whether you prefer a filtered water option, the speed of ice production, and how much storage space is available for ice and water.
- Noise Level: The operational noise of a refrigerator can affect the comfort of your home environment. Look for models that are designed to operate quietly, especially if your kitchen is close to living areas.
- Smart Features: Many modern refrigerators offer smart technology, such as Wi-Fi connectivity and app controls. These features allow you to monitor settings, get alerts, and even manage grocery lists directly from your smartphone.
- Build Quality and Warranty: Assess the materials and craftsmanship of the refrigerator, as this impacts durability and longevity. A strong warranty can provide peace of mind and protect against potential repairs or replacements in the future.
Which Brands are Considered the Best for Side by Side Refrigerators?
The top brands known for their side-by-side refrigerators based on consumer reports include:
- Whirlpool: Known for its reliability and performance, Whirlpool offers a variety of side-by-side models that often come with energy-efficient features and customizable storage options. Their refrigerators are praised for their user-friendly design and innovative technology, ensuring optimal cooling efficiency and food preservation.
- Frigidaire: Frigidaire side-by-side refrigerators are recognized for their affordability without compromising quality. They often feature spacious interiors and adjustable shelving, making it easier to store and organize food items. Many models come equipped with ice and water dispensers, adding convenience to daily use.
- Samsung: Samsung is celebrated for incorporating cutting-edge technology into its side-by-side refrigerators, such as smart connectivity and advanced cooling systems. Their sleek designs often feature a stainless-steel finish, and models frequently include features like ice makers and water filters, enhancing user convenience and style.
- GE Appliances: General Electric (GE) offers a solid lineup of side-by-side refrigerators that are known for their durability and performance. Their models often feature advanced temperature management systems and spacious designs, making them practical for families. Additionally, GE provides a variety of finishes and styles to suit different kitchen aesthetics.
- Bosch: Bosch is synonymous with premium quality and sophisticated design in the appliance market. Their side-by-side refrigerators are often equipped with advanced features such as dual compressors for better temperature control and quiet operation. Their sleek, modern appearance is a favorite among consumers looking for both functionality and style.
- LG: LG refrigerators are well-regarded for their innovative features, including smart technology that allows users to control settings via mobile apps. Their side-by-side models often feature ample storage space and come with advanced cooling technologies to keep food fresher for longer. LG also provides sleek designs that integrate well into contemporary kitchens.
What Are the Top-Rated Side by Side Refrigerators According to Consumer Reports?
The top-rated side-by-side refrigerators according to Consumer Reports include:
- LG LSXS26326S: Known for its spacious interior and advanced cooling technology, this model features a Smart Diagnosis system that allows users to troubleshoot issues via a smartphone app.
- Samsung RS27T5200SR: This refrigerator offers a sleek design with a fingerprint-resistant finish, along with ample storage options and an external ice and water dispenser for convenience.
- Whirlpool WRS325SDHZ: A reliable choice, this model emphasizes energy efficiency and has adjustable shelves, making it easy to organize food and drinks while maintaining optimal cooling performance.
- Frigidaire FFSS2615TS: This affordable option is praised for its straightforward design and dependable performance, featuring bright LED lighting and a spacious freezer for easy access to frozen items.
- GE GSS25GSHSS: With a modern look and features like adjustable door bins and an efficient cooling system, this model is ideal for families needing extra storage and accessibility.
The LG LSXS26326S is appreciated for its innovative features, including the ability to connect to Wi-Fi for diagnostic purposes, ensuring that users can quickly resolve any issues without needing a technician.
The Samsung RS27T5200SR stands out due to its modern aesthetics and user-friendly features, such as the external water and ice dispenser, which offers easy access to chilled beverages without opening the door.
The Whirlpool WRS325SDHZ emphasizes practicality with its energy-efficient design and customizable shelving, allowing users to maximize interior space for various food items while helping to reduce electricity costs.
Frigidaire FFSS2615TS is often recommended for budget-conscious buyers, as it balances performance and affordability, providing ample interior space and user-friendly organization features that are essential for everyday use.
Lastly, the GE GSS25GSHSS combines style and functionality, making it suitable for contemporary kitchens, with adjustable storage options and a reliable cooling system to keep food fresh for longer periods.
What Do Consumer Ratings and Reviews Say About These Refrigerators?
Consumer ratings and reviews offer valuable insights into the performance and reliability of side-by-side refrigerators.
- Energy Efficiency: Many consumers highlight the energy efficiency of certain models, noting that lower energy consumption leads to reduced utility bills. Refrigerators with Energy Star ratings are often praised for their ability to maintain optimal cooling while using less electricity.
- Storage Capacity: Reviews frequently mention the importance of storage capacity, with consumers looking for models that offer ample space for both fresh and frozen items. Many side-by-side refrigerators feature adjustable shelves and compartments that allow users to customize their storage according to their needs.
- Temperature Control: Users emphasize the significance of reliable temperature control, with effective cooling and freezing capabilities being a major selling point. Many reviews note that models with digital temperature displays and precise controls help maintain consistent temperatures for food preservation.
- Design and Aesthetics: The design of side-by-side refrigerators is often a focal point in consumer reviews, with many praising modern finishes and sleek designs that complement kitchen décor. Consumers appreciate features such as built-in water and ice dispensers that not only enhance functionality but also add to the visual appeal.
- Noise Levels: Noise levels are a common concern, with consumers reporting on the operational sounds of their refrigerators. Models that operate quietly tend to receive higher ratings, as they contribute to a more comfortable kitchen environment.
- Durability and Reliability: Many reviews reflect on the long-term durability of side-by-side refrigerators, with consumers sharing their experiences regarding breakdowns and maintenance issues. Brands that consistently deliver reliable performance and require minimal repairs tend to earn positive consumer feedback.
- Customer Service: Consumer ratings often touch on the quality of customer service provided by manufacturers. Positive experiences with warranty claims, parts availability, and support can greatly influence overall satisfaction and lead to favorable reviews.
How Do Prices Vary for Side by Side Refrigerators?
Features: Modern side by side refrigerators often come with a variety of features that can enhance convenience and usability. For example, models equipped with smart technology allow users to control settings via smartphone apps, while built-in water and ice dispensers add to the functionality, all of which can contribute to a higher price tag.
Size and Capacity: The physical dimensions and storage capacity of the refrigerator are key factors in pricing. Typically, larger units designed to hold more food and beverages will be more expensive, as they require more materials and technology to operate effectively.
Energy Efficiency: The energy efficiency of a refrigerator can significantly affect its price. Models that boast high energy efficiency ratings may have a higher initial cost, but they can lead to savings in energy costs over time, making them a more economical choice in the long run.
Sales and Discounts: Shopping during sales events can drastically reduce the prices of side by side refrigerators. Retailers often offer promotions during holidays or clearance events, and taking advantage of these can lead to substantial savings, making high-end models more accessible to consumers.
What Are the Energy Efficiency Ratings of Popular Side by Side Refrigerators?
The energy efficiency ratings of popular side-by-side refrigerators are crucial for consumers looking to save on electricity bills while minimizing environmental impact.
- Energy Star Rating: Refrigerators with an Energy Star rating meet strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
- Annual Energy Consumption (kWh): This metric indicates the estimated amount of electricity a refrigerator uses in a year, helping consumers gauge long-term operating costs.
- Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): The EER is calculated by dividing the cooling capacity of the appliance by its power consumption, providing insight into how efficiently the refrigerator operates under specific conditions.
- Cost of Operation: This figure estimates the annual cost to run the refrigerator based on its energy consumption and local electricity rates, allowing consumers to budget accordingly.
- Refrigerator Size and Capacity: Larger models may consume more energy; understanding the relationship between size and efficiency helps consumers choose the right model for their needs.
Energy Star Rating: Refrigerators with this certification are recognized for their superior energy efficiency, often using 15% less energy than non-certified models. This rating not only signifies lower energy costs for homeowners but also reflects a commitment to environmental sustainability.
Annual Energy Consumption (kWh): This figure provides consumers a clear understanding of how much electricity a refrigerator will use over a year, enabling better comparisons between models. Most manufacturers provide this information on the EnergyGuide label, which is mandated for all refrigerators sold in the U.S.
Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): The EER is particularly valuable as it measures efficiency in real-world performance, factoring in varying temperatures and conditions. A higher EER indicates a more efficient refrigerator, which can lead to significant savings over time.
Cost of Operation: By calculating annual operating costs, consumers can see how energy efficiency translates into actual savings. This metric allows for a more informed decision when investing in a refrigerator, as it highlights the long-term financial implications.
Refrigerator Size and Capacity: While larger refrigerators may offer more storage space, they often come with higher energy requirements. Understanding the trade-off between size and efficiency helps consumers select a model that balances their storage needs with energy use.
What Common Issues Do Consumers Report with Side by Side Refrigerators?
- Temperature Control Problems: Many users experience difficulty maintaining consistent temperatures in both the refrigerator and freezer compartments. This can lead to food spoilage or freezer burn, which is frustrating for consumers who rely on their appliance for food preservation.
- Ice Maker Malfunctions: The ice maker in side by side refrigerators can frequently malfunction, either producing insufficient ice or failing to produce any ice at all. This issue can stem from clogged water lines, faulty motors, or issues with the ice tray, leading to consumer dissatisfaction, especially in households that frequently use ice.
- Noise Levels: Some consumers report that their side by side refrigerators are noisier than expected. This can include sounds from the compressor or the ice maker, which may be bothersome in quiet environments, prompting some users to seek quieter models.
- Storage Space Limitations: While side by side refrigerators are designed to offer ample storage space, many users find that the layout is not as efficient as they hoped. The narrow shelves and divided compartments can make it challenging to store larger items, leading to frustration when trying to organize groceries.
- Energy Efficiency Concerns: Some consumers express concerns regarding the energy efficiency of their side by side refrigerators. Higher energy consumption can lead to increased utility bills, and some users may find that their model does not meet their expectations for energy savings compared to other refrigerator styles.
- Door Seal Issues: Problems with door seals can lead to air leaks, causing temperature fluctuations inside the refrigerator. This not only affects food preservation but can also lead to increased energy consumption as the appliance works harder to maintain the desired temperatures.